Have you ever had a brilliant idea, felt that initial surge of excitement, and then promptly talked yourself out of it? You’re not alone. In fact, research suggests this pattern of self-sabotage through doubt is particularly common among women (Clance & Imes, 1978).
The Mental Trash Can Phenomenon
One of my clients recently made a confession that might sound familiar: “I’ve been unhappy with my career for years. Every time I have an exciting idea for a change, I immediately find 50 reasons why it won’t work. I’ve become an expert at talking myself out of my own dreams.”
This phenomenon—what I call the “mental trash can”—is where our potentially life-changing ideas go to die. According to research by Kross et al. (2014), negative self-talk significantly impairs our ability to perform complex tasks and pursue challenging goals.
The pattern works like this:
- You have an exciting idea
- You immediately measure it against internal doubts and fears
- You find “logical” reasons why it won’t work
- You discard the idea and remain stuck
The Thinking-Results Connection
The foundation of transformative change lies in understanding a simple formula: your thinking creates your feelings, which drive your actions, which produce your results.
When we examine this formula from a neuroscience perspective, it makes perfect sense. Research by Wenzlaff and Wegner (2000) demonstrates that thought suppression and negative thought patterns create neural pathways that become increasingly difficult to override without intervention.
The “Internal Yardstick” Test
Many of us unconsciously measure every idea against what I call our “internal yardstick”—a measuring stick of practicality, experience, and social acceptance. We ask ourselves:
- Is this practical?
- Do I have enough experience?
- What will others think?
When we measure creative ideas against these restrictive criteria, we inevitably throw back the very opportunities that could transform our lives. This pattern is consistent with what psychologists call “cognitive distortions,” particularly catastrophizing and all-or-nothing thinking (Burns, 2008).
A Simple Shift with Profound Impact
A client I worked with was desperately unhappy with her life circumstances. Her mental trash can overflowed with crumpled dreams she’d talked herself out of pursuing. Sound familiar?
When we began working together, I suggested a seemingly simple but powerful thinking shift:
“What if it were possible? What single step could I take right now?”
This approach is supported by research on positive psychology interventions. According to Fredrickson (2001), positive emotions broaden our awareness and encourage novel, varied, and exploratory thoughts and actions. This “broaden-and-build” theory suggests that positive emotions don’t just feel good; they actually expand our possibilities for action.
The Transformation
The shift in my client’s thinking led to remarkable changes. Instead of focusing on all the reasons she couldn’t do something, she began focusing on the possibility that she could.
This “possibility thinking” is directly aligned with Dweck’s (2006) research on growth mindset, which demonstrates that people who believe their talents can be developed through hard work and good strategies tend to achieve more than those with a more fixed mindset.
The result for my client? She ended up moving to another state and landing her dream job—one she’d convinced herself for years was completely out of reach.
Your Turn: From Doubt to Action
What brilliant ideas have you been talking yourself out of? What would your life look like if you asked “What if it were possible?” instead of “Why won’t this work?”
The research is clear: small shifts in thinking patterns can produce dramatic changes in outcomes (Lyubomirsky et al., 2005).
Your next great idea doesn’t belong in the trash can. It belongs in the world. The only question is: What single step could you take today?
Register for my Design A Life You Love: 3 Keys to Achieving Your Goals and Dreams
